Will Tennessee continue to put its money where its tourism is?
By Katie Porterfield
When other candidates were talking tax reform during the 2002 gubernatorial campaign, Gov. Phil
Bredesen cited a need to modernize the state's economy, championing, among other things, tourism as
a means to further economic growth. About two years later, Bredesen's commitment to the industry
manifested itself in the form of a $4.5 million one-time appropriation for the state Department of
Tourist Development to use for media advertising. It brought the department's media buying budget to
about $6.1 millionquite a jump from the $1.6 million the department received in years past.
Tourism commissioner Susan Whitaker requested that money to launch the "The Stage is Set For You"
campaign, and, the next year, she requested and received $4.75 million to continue the campaign. She
got that same amount for 2007-2008 and has requested it again for 2008-2009.
And every year, it has paid off. In 2006, Tennessee's tourism industry contributed $13.4 billion to
the state's economya $1 billion increase for the second consecutive year. According to market
insight and information group TNS Travel and Leisure, every dollar spent on advertising generated
$21 in sales tax revenue, up from about $17 in 2005 and $14 in 2004. That figure doesn't even take
into account the 181,000 Tennesseans employed in the state's tourism industrya number that
also continues to grow. According to the state Department of Labor and Workforce Development, the
leisure and hospitality sector had 8,100 more jobs in October 2007 than in October 2006the
largest increase of any sector.
So, it's apparent that tourism is an economic engine in Tennessee. And despite competing budget
needs, Bredesen says he will "try hard" to maintain the monetary commitment for 2008-2009 because
tourism (and economic development) is the future of revenues for the state.
"When things are tight, it's one of the times you have to keep up the advertising. It's like when
business is tightyou don't want to cut the advertising back very much. You want to keep the
business flowing in," he says. "We are a sales tax-dependent state, and tourism brings nice, fresh,
new people into town who do things and buy things and pay sales tax on them."
He also advocates tourism because in addition to bringing in revenue for the state, it also supports
small businesses.
"While there are some big organizations like Opryland that benefit from it, on the whole, it's a
small business businessit's hotels and motels and attractions and restaurants," he says.
Yet, can the tourism industry sustain its growth, continuing to weather economic blows that this
year extend well beyond the rising gas prices to include a weakening housing market and a slowdown
in consumer spending? Whitaker says, "yes," and she thinks the tourism industry could be a bright
spot in an otherwise sluggish economy.
"When the economy gets rocky, people do travelthey just may not go as far, which actually
makes Tennessee a better option because two-thirds of the U.S. population is within a day's drive,"
Whitaker says. "With the right advertising, we believe we can be a leveler to keep dollars up."
So far, the annual growth rates indicate that gas prices have not yet dramatically affected
Tennessee's tourism industry.
"It may be slowing our growth, but it's not bringing it to a halt by any means," Whitaker says.
Beyond the numbers, though, state attractions set to open this year serve as further evidence that
business is booming. The $110 million Belle Island Village project, which contains 126 hotel rooms,
95 retail locations and four restaurants, is scheduled to open in Pigeon Forge this fall. The
project also includes attractions such as the Debbie Reynolds Hollywood Motions Picture Museum and
the Darrel Waltrip Racing Experience, which features an interactive theater, competition
radio-controlled cars, a racing car simulator, pit crew area, arcade and exhibits showcasing stock
cars.
And while tourism officials throughout the state commend Bredesen's commitment and agree that the
state's investment in the industry has come a long way, they would still like to see more in the way
of funding.
"The states that are truly serious about tourism, like Florida and California, really don't hold
back when it comes to tourism marketing dollars," says Pace Cooper, president and CEO of Cooper
Companies, builders and managers of hotel properties across Tennessee and the United States.
Tennessee ranks 13th among states in terms of the 2006-2007 projected domestic advertising budget,
according to the latest "Survey of U.S. State & Territory Tourism Office Budgets." The state
recorded a budget projection total of $7.1 million (which includes media buying and creative cost
projections). California tops the list, appropriating $15 million to the cause, and number five,
Florida, boasts an $11 million budget. To crack the top 10, Tennessee would have to climb over South
Carolina, which reported $7.3 million, Arkansas, which reported $7.7 million, and number 10, New
Jersey, which reported $8.8 million. That should certainly be a goal for the state and would be a
valuable step toward accelerating the commitment to this powerful economic force.
Protect the Goose
Gov. Phil Bredesen has been touting tourism as part of a recent emphasis on spurring more jobs and
development in the state's rural areas. This is a push that could pay dividends for Tennessee, but
there's another initiative out there that not only complements that effort, but also ensures that
the state protects the very resources that make it a beautiful place to visit. In April, the
Department of Tourist Development, UT-Knoxville, Middle Tennessee State University and the National
Geographic Society are sponsoring the first Great Smoky Mountains Sustainable Tourism Summit in
Knoxville. Aimed at protecting Tennessee's landscapes, the summit seeks to address concerns
regarding how to sustain strong economic growth, while also sustaining the natural beauty of the
Great Smoky Mountains National Park and its gateway communities. Sustainable tourism is important to
Tennessee's future.
"If you ruin the very resources that bring people to your state, you've killed the goose that laid
the golden egg," says Susan Whitaker, commissioner of the Tennessee Department of Tourist
Development.
And it's a golden egg that the state is counting on this year.